Friday, May 23, 2008

Chambon's Link to the Holocaust

I think that it is great to hear about a town that went against all rules just to help out their fellow "men." At a time when one could easily be killed for doing such a thing, the people there hid Jews and gave them everything that they needed anyways. One "refugee" even said that he was not once asked whether or not he was Jewish. That shows true empathy on Chambon's part. The "conspiracy of good" was something that led to the honor at Yad Vashem, something I feel that they truly deserve. However, I feel that it is too bad that their heroism is so rarely talked about. Their story should definitely be in textbooks and talked about in French schools so that they can feel proud of their actions. Chambon has not gotten enough recognition for the part that they played in preserving a race. Genocide was not in their vocabulary at all! They should be proud.

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

"Did Communism Threaten America's International Security After World War II?"

I agree more with Richard M. Fried's "no" argument. Communism's "red scares" share too many similarities with the Salem witch trials back in 1692, especially since Joseph McCarthy went severely overboard with his accusations. I do not truly believe that there were half as many Communists as he claimed there were. It is truly ridiculous how Hollywood actors, teachers, and other prestigious people were accused. They had done nothing wrong at all! In addition, Fried makes a good point when he says that Americans' first and fifth amendments were violated because they couldn't really do anything without being accused of being Communists. Many government officials were also wrongly accused. I think that McCartney was just trying to get attention, and that he went way off track when doing so. The lists that he had of supposed Communists did not even originate from a legitimate source! In conclusion, I believe that the "witch trials" of the 1950's and the McCarthyism that accompanied it posed much bigger threats to the American people than actual Communism did. A mountain was most certainly made out of a molehill.

Friday, April 4, 2008

Dropping the Atomic Bomb

Dropping the atomic bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki was not justified at all on our part. The main issue is that hundreds of thousands of Japanese citizens were killed on impact either from the bomb or from the radiation that followed it. These were not just the people who had bombed Pearl Harbor, but rather innocent children and other innocent citizens who had done nothing to deserve their fate. I am sure that many more Americans would have spoken up about the catastrophe that we caused if they had known someone who was directly affected by it, but the sad fact is that, for many Americans, it did not affect them directly, so they kept quiet about the issue. We should have come up with some other way to punish the people who had directly attacked us, and only those people. At the time, Japan was believed to have been "leaving" the war soon anyways. America made an aggressive and ill-founded decision because the end of the war was coming shortly. In addition, the bombing made us look inhumane and uncaring. It also "singled us out" in a negative way. In conclusion, America's decision to bomb Hiroshima and Nagasaki was not necessary, and it helped further portray us as a ruthless and aggressive country.

Tuesday, March 4, 2008

World War I Reaction Essay

The book excerpt Eye Deep in Hell, Trench Warfare in World War I is an amazingly written account of the tragedies that occurred during this "war to end all wars." It provides an in-depth description of the heroic soldiers' everyday lives and of the horrors they witnessed and/or endured. These horrors range anywhere from trench foot to mud to cold winters to rats, lice, and much more. Although many citizens felt aware of the catastrophes in Europe, the average citizen could not possibly imagine what these men had to go through in the true sense of the words.
I truly enjoyed reading the excerpts because they opened my eyes to the true nature of the suffering that happened in the war. First of all, I was not aware that trench foot was such an issue. I did not even truly know what it was in fact. So many men had toes amputated because of it! When I initially pictured the war, I pictured more deaths from cold weather and fighting than I did from wet feet. Second of all, I did not know that the soldiers went to such an extent just to get rid of lice. I simply figured that they dealt with it just as much as they did any other bothersome conditions. Third of all, the "mud issue" truly shocked me. Who would have ever thought that men could essentially be swallowed by muck?
In conclusion, I feel that the reading was necessary to expand my knowledge of conditions during World War I. Many Americans did not know of the rats and the disease, of the stench and of the mud. These excerpts definitely "humanized" the situation and made it easy for me to picture the horrible conditions. Fighting was not the only issue that transformed the war into a living hell, and the soldiers relearned that brutal lesson each and every day.

World War I Diary Entries

Mark Platopat
March 12, 1916
London
08:00 PM



What a horrible day! At first I believed Wilson, and his promise for the "war to end all wars," but now I am not so sure. Conditions are terrible! He probably meant that this will kill off people so there are not enough for fighting future wars. Ha! What a joke. Anyways, the mud is killing me. It is by far the worst natural nightmare. Some men have been trapped up to their neck in it, and many die from the stuff too!

The most important thing that I can do is to distribute my body weight evenly. That is the key to survival. All these stupid trenches are good for are killing an otherwise sound man. Ugh. The frustration alone is killing me. Even walking is a chore. With the mud, one can not step very fast. When this war is over, I will surely come out with nothing more than strengthened leg muscles. The mud is even clogging the weapons! I can't even write a proper journal entry...



Mark Platopat
March 13, 1916
London
09:00 PM



Great! I got trench foot today! It's just another thing to add to the list. I have never even heard of trench foot before today, and I surely will never forget it! I should have known that these damp conditions would cause some kind of problems. Is it really normal to wear wet socks and boots for days on end? At first, I thought that it was just frostbite, but apparently not. All of these fancy names make me sick.
To best describe what happened, my feet went numb at first. Then they turned a reddish-blue color. That sure scared me to death! I was so frightened that I would have to lose some toes, like Paul did. I feel bad for the poor fellow. All he did was try to make his country proud. As far as I know, they discovered about fifty cases or so today. I can't believe that they didn't notice anything sooner! This will surely pose a threat to our unit's strength as a whole. If it isn't one thing, it's another...


Mark Platopat
December 08, 1916
London
08:45 PM

I haven't written in awhile, but conditions have been really harsh lately. The winter is completely dragging us down. All I can really think about is the terrible cold. My lack of clothes is seriously contributing to my problems. Everyone literally has to jump around in order to keep the blood flowing in their veins because it appears to want to freeze us from the inside out. We have had to deal with these issues since October! What a long winter it will be!
My boiling hot tea actually froze solid in a few hours! Rain, snow, and sleet are guaranteed daily occurrences. The alternating periods of extreme cold and thawing made a grand ole recipe for mud as well...And standing in water usually leads to being surrounded by a ridiculous sheet of ice. Our braziers do not really work all that well, so I guess I have to deal with the cold like everyone else is. After all, this is a war, not some luxurious vacation.

Tuesday, February 19, 2008

America's Real Reasons for Imperialism

I think that America's "foray into imperialism" was caused mostly by its strong belief in Anglo-Saxon superiority. Our country, at the time, felt almost invincible, and strongly believed in a "survival of the fittest" kind of world, in which Americans were the fittest. Because of this overinflated ego, our citizens worked to Christianize and assimilate other cultures in order to make them less like aliens and more like what we thought decent people should be. In addition, the United States felt that it would be doomed and easily pushed around if it did not annex certain territories. Our acquisition of various territories, to put it simply, ensured that we were not far behind other countries and their achievements. Our presidents quickly gave in to this form of peer pressure, and in the meantime, guaranteed our spot as a world power. Various other endeavors clearly show our independent, carefree, and almost conceited view of our country. In the end, it all comes down to our country's belief that it is better and more powerful than anything or anyone it sets out to conquer.

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Martin Luther King Jr.

I think that it's too bad that the only thing that comes to mind when people mention Martin Luther King Jr. is the "I have a dream" speech. In my opinion, Martin Luther King Jr. is not as looked up to as he should be. There are so many people nowadays who are more famous for doing less! It is not that I think he should be extremely popular, but I do believe that he should be acknowledged more, as well as his message. The article makes a good point when it states that he was in fact fighting for unpopular things. We as citizens today should pay more attention to how he lived his life, and model that. By doing so, we will see real change because he not only fought for racial equality, but anti-poverty and war issues as well. I truly admire King, and I wish that he had more recognition, and that we actually celebrated the day that is named after him! Many people do not even remember, or know, when Martin Luther King Jr. day is! I hope that Barack Obama becomes President because he seems as if he is a strong believer in equality and change, just like King was. Hopefully someday King will be known and remembered for much more than that one speech!